– Peter Pan is evil - Peter Pan is the true Villain of the story
-Neverland is a world that caters to his every desire. He’s the dictator of that realm. Whatever he says, goes. That’s a lot of power—maybe too much power—for a hero to possess.
–When Neverland gets too crowded with lost boys, Peter Pan thins out the herd.
This is murder. This is execution
–He cares little for Wendy or her family apart from their ability to amuse him. When bored, he’ll just find another Wendy to take away.
These are intriguing arguments. But the most compelling piece of evidence is the sum of all this. Peter Pan is basically selfish. He’s a self-involved character who refuses to grow up, and who creates an entire world—Neverland—which is his to rule.
When you look at Peter Pan in this way — as a character whose growth has been stunted — it’s fitting that he loses his shadow.
he is murderous psychopath that kills both his own crew and his “enemies” pirates and indians (although most likely the pirates were originally his own men)
Peter rules Neverland like a volatile and narcissistic child-dictator. He demands absolute obedience, plays make-believe games where children must pretend to eat imaginary food, and physically alters or punishes Lost Boys if they become "too fat or lumpy" for their tree-trunk homes
A famous and chilling line in the original story notes that when the Lost Boys start to grow up—which violates Neverland's rules—Peter "thins them out", implying he murders or banishes them to preserve eternal youth
Peter possesses a dangerously short memory and zero genuine empathy. He forgets people moments after they leave, including Wendy and her brothers during flights, and treats life and death with a flippant attitude ("To die will be an awfully big adventure")
– Captain Hook. We’ve always believed he was the villain. But think about it: Peter Pan cut his hand off and fed it to a crocodile. No wonder Hook is pissed.
, Hook (formerly James, one of the original Lost Boys who dared to grow up) was hunted and mutilated by Peter—who famously cut off Hook's hand and fed it to the crocodile. Hook’s vendetta is driven by survival and revenge against a psychopathic entity who traps children in an endless, violent loop
Many fans have adopted the notion that Captain James Hook is actually the good guy as Peter Pan is the antagonist, with the ideas that many of Hook's "pirates" are actually exiled Lost Boys who escaped Peter's gang or the Boys who found the truth of Peter's true evil intentions towards them and so Hook promised them a better future in his crew.